Recycling Nuclear Waste and Breeder Reactors

By Nick Touran, March 2009

What is nuclear recycling?

Nuclear waste is recyclable. Once reactor fuel (uranium or thorium) is used in a reactor, it can be treated and put into another reactor as fuel. In fact, typical reactors only extract a few percent of the energy in their fuel. You could power the entire US electricity grid off of the energy in nuclear waste for almost 100 years (details). If you recycle the waste, the final waste that is left over decays to harmlessness within a few hundred years, rather than a million years as with standard (unrecycled) nuclear waste. This page explains how this interesting process is possible.

Nuclear Transformations

An image of U-238 becoming Pu-239 via neutron absorption and two beta-decays.

Before you go on, recall that Uranium exists in nature as 2 isotopes: the less common U-235, and the more common U-238. Conventional reactors mainly split U-235 to produce power, and the U-238 is often considered useless. When a standard reactor runs low on U-235, it must be refueled, even though there is a lot of U-238 still in there.

A common type of nuclear reaction is called beta-decay. When a nucleus has more neutrons than it would like to have, it often beta-decays by breaking a neutron into a proton and an electron. The electron (called a beta-particle in this case, since it originated in the nucleus) flies off into nature, and the main result seen in the nucleus is a neutron converting to a proton (see figure).

When U-238 absorbs a neutron in a nuclear reactor, it becomes U-239, which is just the isotope of Uranium with one extra neutron than U-238. This beta-decays quickly and becomes Np-239. Then, the Np-239 beta-decays again to become Pu-239, which is a fissile isotope that can power nuclear reactors.

The “useless” U-238 is the secret to recycling nuclear fuel. When it absorbs a single neutron, it goes through a series of nuclear reactions within a few days and turns into a very splittable isotope of Plutonium, Pu-239. The Pu-239 acts a lot like the U-235 that powers conventional reactors, so if you convert your U-238 to Pu-239 as you run your reactor, you can then use that Pu-239 to continue powering your reactor, or others!

Nuclear Fuel cycles

A nuclear fuel cycle is the path that nuclear fuel (Uranium, Thorium, Plutonium, etc.) takes as it is used to generate power in a nuclear reactor. Our fuel cycle page has more info. They describe where the material comes from and where it ends up. Different fuel cycles range from very simple to fairly complicated. We describe several of these below.

Once Through Cycle

A picture of a once through fuel cycle

Figure 1. A once-through fuel cycle. Put your mouse over each image for more info.

The simplest fuel cycle is the once-through cycle. It is the de-facto standard in most operating nuclear power plants, with a few exceptions in Europe and Asia. Uranium is mined, enriched, used in a reactor (where it becomes radioactive nuclear waste), and then stored until it is no longer dangerously radioactive. While this cycle is cheap, there are two major problems with it. Firstly, the waste is radioactive for hundreds of thousands of years. No one has been able to design a repository that is convincingly capable of storing material for that long. Secondly, Uranium is not the most abundant element on Earth, and in this kind of cycle, the global supply of cheap uranium could run low within 200 years. So much for sustainability! There are some deep-burn once-through cycles out there that have good sustainability properties though.

Natural uranium ore is extracted from the ground at the mine. The enrichment plant increases the concentration of U-235 in the natural uranium up to around 4 percent. This is enriched Uranium, with about 4 percent U-235 and the rest U-238. This is a regular reactor, of which there are about 100 of in the USA. It is water cooled and requires enriched uranium. When the reactor runs for a few years, the waste is made up of depleted uranium (with very little U-235 left), plutonium and other actinides, and the fission products. In a once through cycle, the waste goes straight into a waste repository, where it is supposed to stay for up to a million years.

Closed Fuel Cycle

A picture of a MOX recycle fuel cycle.

Figure 2. A closed fuel cycle. Here nuclear material is recycled. Put your mouse over each image for more info.

Closing the fuel cycle involves recycling the nuclear waste as new fuel. Since the main component of nuclear waste is Uranium-238 (which can be transmuted to Plutonium, especially with advanced breeder reactors), we can get more energy out of the waste than in a once-through cycle (see factoid 2 to see how much). The recycling plant separates the good stuff from the bad stuff. The bad stuff is mostly fission products, the atoms that a Uranium atom becomes after it splits in the fission process. These fission products mostly decay to safe levels within 300-500 years, which is significantly shorter than standard nuclear waste. So, by closing the fuel cycle with standard reactors, we address the issue of nuclear waste identified in the once-through cycle. In this case, nuclear waste is a tractable problem. But most of the reactivity is coming from the mine, since standard reactors burn most of the fissile nuclide, U-235. Also, the reprocessing technology is expensive and separates out pure Plutonium, which could possibly be stolen, bringing a rogue entity closer to having a nuclear weapon. For these reasons, the USA does not currently recycle. There are ways to solve these issues.

Natural uranium ore is extracted from the ground at the mine. The enrichment plant increases the concentration of U-235 in the natural uranium up to around 4 percent. This is enriched Uranium, with about 4 percent U-235 and the rest U-238. This is a regular reactor, of which there are about 100 of in the USA. It is water cooled and requires enriched uranium. When the reactor runs for a few years, the waste is made up of depleted uranium (with very little U-235 left), plutonium and other actinides, and the fission products. The depleted uranium and the plutonium from the reprocessing plant can be put back into the reactor in place of enriched uranium because the plutonium splits readily, just like U-235. The recycling plant chemically separates the nuclear waste into depleted uranium, plutonium, and the fission products. These are the atoms that uranium or plutonium split into, so they are about half as large as Uranium. They are often radioactive, but decay to stability much faster than standard nuclear waste, which includes heavy actinides like Plutonium, Americium, and Neptunium. Since the fission products decay to stability on the order of 300 years, the repository does not need to last for a million years, as it does with standard nuclear waste.

Breeder Fuel Cycle

A picture of a breeder recycle fuel cycle.

Breeder reactors can create as much or more fissile material (atoms that readily split) than they use. These special reactors are designed to have extra neutrons flying around, so that some can convert U-238 to Pu-239 (see above) and the others can run the reactor. Often, these special reactors are deemed "fast" reactors because the neutrons are moving through the reactor at higher speeds, on average. In a full breeder fuel cycle, we get the maximum use of the Uranium resources on Earth, and what we already know exists can last tens of thousands of years. The cycle has cost and proliferation concerns associated with any closed cycle. Additionally, we have significantly less operational experience with breeder reactors, so we would need to train builders and operators for such a machine. Using a Thorium cycle instead of a Uranium-Plutonium cycle may allow breeding in less exotic reactors. Using this kind of fuel cycle, nuclear power can truly be considered sustainable.

Questions? Send them in!

Natural uranium ore is extracted from the ground at the mine. The enrichment plant increases the concentration of U-235 in the natural uranium up to around 4 percent. This is enriched Uranium, with about 4 percent U-235 and the rest U-238. Breeder reactors make more fissile material than they consume. They have been built before, but are not in common use. Waste from breeder reactors will have the same basic components as standard nuclear waste, but it will have significantly more fissile material in it (Plutonium or U-233 from a Thorium cycle) Some of the breeders waste can be used to refuel the breeder for another cycle. The recycling plant chemically separates the nuclear waste into depleted uranium, plutonium, and the fission products. Since the breeder makes extra fissile material, it can fuel several other reactors as well as itself. Since the fission products decay to stability on the order of 300 years, the repository does not need to last for a million years, as it does with standard nuclear waste. These are the atoms that uranium or plutonium split into, so they are about half as large as Uranium. They are often radioactive, but decay to stability much faster than standard nuclear waste, which includes heavy actinides like Plutonium, Americium, and Neptunium. These can be standard water reactors or more breeder reactors. The waste from these plants can also be recycled in a closed fuel cycle.

Additional Reading

  1. Implications of Partitioning and Transmutation in Radioactive Waste Management, IAEA Technical Reports Series 435
  2. Our fuel cycle page
  3. Our explanation of enrichment
  4. Our nuclear waste page
  5. Our Breeder reactors page
  6. Yucca Mountain (Wikipedia)

The next stop

Go on to our non-proliferation page to find out about the relationships between nuclear energy and nuclear weapons.